Investigating a Murder Accusation

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
22 Jul 2024

The recent declaration by the Modi government to observe June 25 as "Constitution Murder Day" marks yet another attempt by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) to manipulate historical events for political gain. This move, purportedly to pay tribute to those who suffered during the Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi in 1975, is deeply ironic given the BJP's own record of undermining democratic institutions and constitutional values.

Despite its notorious legacy, the Emergency was enacted within the constitutional framework. It was a dark period in Indian history marked by state excesses, but then the checks and balances of democracy were eventually restored through the electoral process within 18 months. Though guilty of significant overreach, Indira Gandhi's government ultimately faced accountability through the ballot box.

In stark contrast, the Modi government's tenure has been characterised by systematic assaults on the pillars of democracy for a decade. From undermining the independence of the judiciary and other institutions to considering the parliament as his own backyard, the BJP has consistently flouted constitutional norms.

The declaration of "Constitution Murder Day" serves as a smokescreen, diverting attention from the BJP's own anti-democratic actions. It is an attempt to reframe historical records and vilify political adversaries while distracting the public from the continuously worsening real and present issues. Prominent RSS ideologues have openly criticised the Constitution, advocating instead for the Manusmriti, a text that contradicts the core values of equality and justice enshrined in our Constitution. The push was evident as a shot was made to incorporate it into the undergraduate law curriculum at Delhi University.

The true threat to our Constitution lies not in historical episodes like the Emergency but in the ongoing efforts to erode democratic norms and institutions. It's crucial for citizens to recognise these manipulations and hold the government accountable. Upholding the Constitution requires vigilance against both overt authoritarianism and subtle subversions.

RSS supremo Mohan Bhagwat's recent forays into indirect criticisms of the BJP have failed to impress anyone. After the BJP's carrot-and-stick policy, such displays, supported by the enslaved media, seem like a good cop-bad cop show. They must re-educate their cadre unconditionally so that anti-citizen behaviour, such as stopping educational funds for states that refuse to buckle under them, will not be tolerated. If such behaviour is allowed to continue, mayhap the day will come when the observations he made in his speech will be realised against the RSS.

The Constitution was not murdered by Indira Gandhi. The proof is that the BJP even came to power. If it had been murdered then, the carnage in Gujarat and elsewhere might never have been unleashed. Yet, it is now on its deathbed under Modiji, who is choking it under the guise of "sabka vikaas." The very federal nature of India is being denied under the incumbent government. One day, the people who proudly fly their saffron banners will realise that it has become their downfall.

Recent Posts

Dear fellow Indians, friends of India, and all well-wishers: Not often does one get to witness history being written. Before our eyes, we see history happen in the very NOW. We read in history book
apicture Stanislaus Alla
12 Oct 2026
A fundamental distinction must be maintained between carefully examining a case's facts and rejecting an institution's application on that basis, and making sweeping generalisations about an entire re
apicture Adv. Rev. Dr George Thekkekara
12 Oct 2026
Vismaya's public dissent, Riya's demand for justice, and Yashaswinee's defiance of political inheritance are a growing sign that young women are refusing to remain silent spectators. Their courage in
apicture A. J. Philip
12 Oct 2026
The book "Politics, Policy and Predictions: Views from the Front Row of Parliament" by Derek O'Brien, Rajya Sabha MP and leader of the All India Trinamool Congress Parliamentary Party, throws light on
apicture Marydasan John
12 Oct 2026
As Leader of the Opposition, Rahul Gandhi waves the national Tricolour from atop police barricades, and Union Cabinet ministers celebrate Prime Minister Narendra Modi's dubious silver jubilee—13 years
apicture John Dayal
12 Oct 2026
Gandhi need not return as another Mahatma. He can live through a generation that resists hatred without hatred, confronts injustice without violence, challenges consumerism, defends the marginalised a
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
12 Oct 2026
Formation is not merely about producing priests and religious who follow rules, recite the Creed and wear habits. It is about nurturing conviction, maturity and integrity.
apicture Fr. Anil Prakash D'Souza, OP
12 Oct 2026
What exactly are we celebrating when our festivities leave children gasping, elders struggling to breathe, animals terrified, and the air poisoned? Culture evolves with human understanding. The real t
apicture P. A. Chacko
12 Oct 2026
The press is the voice of the people. It carries the complaint of the pensioner, the cry of the assaulted woman, the anger of the unemployed graduate and the question the powerful would prefer nobody
apicture Robert Clements
12 Oct 2026
Corrective press notes are not substitutes for accountability. This crisis demands independent investigation, judicial scrutiny and reversal of the SIR. Institutional complicity is the gravest betraya
apicture Oliver D'Souza
05 Oct 2026