India and Israel: Reflection of the World Today

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
15 Apr 2024

It is no secret that democracy has been on the decline worldwide. The steady regression of global freedom for the last 19 years casts a shadow over the very essence of democracy. Around one-fifth of the world's population is affected by the erosion of their rights. Attacks on pluralism, the bedrock of peaceful coexistence amidst diverse political, religious, and ethnic identities, have become rampant.

The integrity of elections faces threats beyond manipulation, including violence and poor administration. Instances of violence sideline candidates and deter citizens from exercising their voting rights, while a crisis of confidence in electoral institutions fosters apathy, weakening the legitimacy of elected governments. This erosion of trust creates a fertile ground for authoritarianism to thrive domestically and internationally.

Israel's democratic regression began well before the recent conflict in Gaza. Discriminatory practices, mainly aimed at gaining control over the occupied West Bank, have contributed significantly to this decline. Meanwhile, legal changes within Israel itself have further eroded the democratic principle of equal treatment under the law, with over 65 laws passing to codify discrimination against non-Jewish Israelis. The judiciary, traditionally a check on political power, faced increased attempts to weaken its oversight powers in 2023.

India's freedom in the World score has steadily declined since 2013, coinciding with widespread violence against religious minorities under Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Indian-administered Kashmir has witnessed a significant decline in freedom, moving from Partly Free to Not Free in 2019 following the revocation of its special autonomous status. The region has since experienced increased repression, extrajudicial violence, and lack of independence as a Union Territory.

This repression aligns with the rise of Hindu nationalism in India, characterised by policies and violence against religious minorities. Furthermore, instances of media censorship and attacks on critical journalists and outlets and involvement in targeting activists overseas with assassination plots, as accused by Canada and the US, further undermine its credentials.

In Eurasia, elections often serve as mere charades, masking autocrats' grip on power. Vladimir Putin's two-decade and continuing reign epitomises the hollow democracy prevalent in the region. Rigged elections, coupled with systematic suppression of opposition voices, independent media, and judicial autonomy, have suffocated dissent. One wonders why these terms sound so familiar!

The tale of two nations, India and Israel, does not concern only these countries but also reflects the mindset of the nations that support or sponsor them. The data underscores the severity of the situation, with 35 countries receiving the worst scores for free and fair elections. This concerning trend, which has escalated since 2005, stems from a dual onslaught of rigged elections and military coups. While coups are apparent, rigged elections, though visible, tend to be whitewashed over.

As the world faces increasing hostility towards pluralism and diverse identities, democracies must uphold inclusive principles domestically and abroad. Despite the rise of illiberal leaders and isolationist rhetoric, fostering partnerships based on shared democratic values remains crucial to reversing this unhealthy trend. Only through collective efforts to support open media, uphold democratic institutions, and condemn repression can democracies confront authoritarianism and safeguard freedom.

Recent Posts

How will they believe that when you see a Muslim lawyer or litigant in your court, you will not see a "Kathmullah" in him? That is the kind of scare you have created. Now, ask your own conscience whet
apicture A. J. Philip
16 Dec 2024
With incidents like CJI Chandrachud's controversial actions and judges displaying communal biases, the saffronisation of the judiciary is clearly visible. While some still uphold constitutional values
apicture P. A. Chacko
16 Dec 2024
Pope Francis elaborated that walking in the path of Jesus means "to return to him and to put him back at the centre of everything," warning against secondary concerns and external appearances that can
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
16 Dec 2024
Despite protests and worsening conditions, the government continues to play hooky. Instead of focussing on serious issues imperative to the true growth of the country, the BJP-RSS is still honking the
apicture Prakash Louis
16 Dec 2024
Rising communal tensions, driven by divisive politics, growing religiosity, and media propaganda, have disrupted the social fabric of even far-flung villages that had been historically tolerant. Villa
apicture Dr. Arun Kumar Oraon
16 Dec 2024
The Gujarat identity was rooted in Hinduism and directed against Muslims. It had been a Hindu nationalist test site, a new form of Hindutva politics that unfolded at the national level. Modi, as the P
apicture G Ramachandram
16 Dec 2024
Though the NDA allies have won a sweeping victory in Maharashtra, there's still a sense of unease all over the state. Hardly any firecrackers went off on the day of the results, and victory celebratio
apicture Robert Clements
16 Dec 2024
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) established fundamental principles of equality, including women's rights. Despite some progress like the CEDAW, women continue to face violence, discri
apicture Adv Jessy Kurian
09 Dec 2024
The UN's International Day for Elimination of Violence Against Women highlights alarming global gender-based violence, including in India, where cases rise yearly. Rooted in societal norms and stigma,
apicture Dr. Minakshi Sardar
09 Dec 2024
Himanta Biswa Sarma's trajectory has been incredible! He has taken to BJP propaganda like fish to water. His policies, like the latest beef ban in Assam, mirror BJP policies really well, where they pr
apicture A. J. Philip
09 Dec 2024