Cry for Justice, not Mercy

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
20 Jun 2022
Editorial - Justice for Dalit Christians

Dalits, in every religion, face discrimination. The intensity of bias may vary, but its sting is felt, in one or other form, in every religion and community. It was this untold unfairness that led to one of the largest conversions ever happened in the history of India. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar led 3,65,000 of his followers to leave the Hindu-fold and embraced Buddhism. Of course, there had been umpteen initiatives in Independent India to put an end to the Dalit subversion and unfair treatment meted out to them. It is in this context one has to look at the plight of Dalit Christians. The issue has layered nuances that touch upon various aspects of their life, and we are restricting the topic with reference to the Catholic Church only.

To start with, one burning issue that continues to strangulate their identity as Christians is the segregation they face in the Church and its related institutions. It is ridiculous, and most uncharitable, that Dalit Catholics, in churches, are barred from occupying seats with their high caste counterparts. Even more outrageous is the practice of disallowing them to be buried in the same cemetery where non-Dalits are entombed. It is nothing less than the burial of the fundamental Christian values of love, justice and mercy. The CBCI document on Dalit Catholics does accept the existence of these unchristian practices in the following words: “Social segregation extends to the sphere of worship and religious rituals, with separate churches and priests being almost the norm among Dalit Christians. Subordination in churches as well as insistence on separate burial grounds is not uncommon.” But the Church hierarchy has failed to find a solution to this vexed problem.  

Dalit empowerment can come only with education and enhanced skills. It is the stepping stone to better career opportunities, improved economic status and better living standards. The Church recognizes this in its document stating that "No Catholic child, Dalit/tribal or otherwise, should be deprived of quality education because of a lack of means… We make this preferential option, even if in this process academic results suffer. All Catholic schools, whether run by dioceses the religious, corporate bodies or individuals, are expected to participate in this project.” But the question lingers on: Has this ‘prescription’ found its way to the campuses run by the Church or institutions linked to it? Many considerations seem to have subverted this benign proposal. Till it happens, the ills affecting the Dalit Catholics will not be remedied in the near future.

Dalit Catholics suffer from lack of remunerative employment opportunities, especially due to the government’s irrational decision to deny job reservation for them. This is despite the Supreme Court’s acceptance that caste discrimination continues even after conversion. The denial of reservation to them is the single most injustice to this community. Though the Church is taking up cudgels on this issue, it has not reached anywhere in the face of a stubborn government. Hence, a more practical approach would be to do whatever possible within the Church in appointments. Let there be a commitment on its part that it would set apart a certain per centage of its appointments for Dalit Catholics. Here the policy document is clear in its objective: “Proportionate representation is to be ensured to the eligible Dalit Christian candidates in jobs, at all levels, in all Christian institutions.” Are the authorities concerned listening to this dictum? 

Editorial Dalits Dalit Christians Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Buddhism Catholic Church Christians Dalit Catholics Dalit Empowerment Supreme Court Caste Descrimination Issue 26 2022 Indian Currents Indian Currents Magazine

Recent Posts

India's oldest mountain range is facing its most modern threat. As mining expands and legal definitions narrow, the Aravallis' role as a climate shield, water source, and wildlife corridor is being qu
apicture Joseph Jerald SJ
05 Jan 2026
India was built by defying religious orthodoxy, not sanctifying it. Science, education and equality advanced when prejudice was challenged—and regressed whenever cultural nationalism revives the fears
apicture A. J. Philip
05 Jan 2026
The end of a year offers individuals, institutions, nations, and the global community an opportunity for introspection and learning from the experiences of the past twelve months. Life is a blend of s
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 Jan 2026
The 2025 Zilla Panchayat elections exposed how local self-governance in Goa has been overtaken by high-stakes party politics. BJP's all-out mobilisation contrasted sharply with the fragmented Oppositi
apicture Pachu Menon
05 Jan 2026
In recent years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has repeatedly reached out to India's Christian community. On several occasions, especially around Christmas, he has visited churches, hosted gatherings w
apicture Bishop Savio Fernandes
05 Jan 2026
Christmas violence against Christians is diagnostic. It is a stress test of India's constitutional guarantees. Vigilantes policing public celebration with impunity is an attack on civic space.
apicture Oliver D'Souza
05 Jan 2026
Give work to all the hands Give wages to all the families
apicture Prakash Louis
05 Jan 2026
I was born like anyone else. Yet I was never treated like anyone else. The name Pariah was given to me. And its meaning was carved into my skin.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
05 Jan 2026
While Xi Jinping was at Mahabalipuram admiring Indian art and listening to Modi's 'political wisdom,' the People's Liberation Army was pushing the Chinese frontier in the Galwan Valley. The Chinese sp
apicture Archbp Thomas Menamparampil
05 Jan 2026