Twisting the Law

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
15 Feb 2021

A law is meant to save the victim, not to provide a safety gear to the culprit through contrived loopholes in it. It is meant to punish the guilty, not to protect them. This is all the more so about laws intended to protect children. Protection of Children against Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act is meant to provide ‘impenetrable’ shield to children. In a country where as many as 130 children are abused every day, as per the latest report of the Crime Records Bureau, the protection of a stringent law is inevitable. Unfortunately, the law is made to stand on its head by judges with jaundiced eyes as happened in the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court. A person convicted under POCSO Act by a lower court was treated with kid gloves when the High Court judge decided to punish him under a much lenient section of Indian Penal Code instead of the POCSO Act.     

The case against the accused was clear. He had lured a girl to a room, pressed her breasts and tried to undress her. It is a case of sexual assault under section 7 of the POCSO Act. The lower court judge convicted and punished him accordingly. However, the High Court judge, under a weird argument that there was no ‘skin-to-skin’ contact, tried him under IPC and handed out just one-year jail term instead of three to five years under POCSO Act. 

In yet another case of child sex abuse, the same judge set free a man who had unzipped pants in front of a girl. The judge could not see any sexual abuse in this act and acquitted the accused. The above verdicts are the result of twisting of the law which is meant to be a deterrent against those who indulge in sexual offence against children.  

The judge of the Bombay High Court is not alone when it comes to tweaking the law to suit the accused. In bail applications, as seen in many recent cases, judges have apparently given verdicts to help powerful persons. When influential persons could approach the apex court and elicit favourable verdicts, many ordinary mortals have been told to approach the lower courts first to seek relief. Judicial insensitivity was exposed when octogenarian Stan Swamy, who cannot even hold a glass of water due to illness, had to knock at the doors of the court for weeks together for obtaining a piece of plastic straw. He is among the several human rights activists languishing in jail for backing a Dalit rally in Bhima Koregaon in Maharashtra. We have also witnessed stand-up comedians being put behind bars for the jokes they made which in no way leave even a scratch on the government.     

Thus, we come across several instances of inconsistent verdicts wherein judges indulge in hair-splitting exercise to limit or tweak the scope of the law. In some cases, the verdicts are unmistakably made to suit those who sing paeans to the government. In some other cases, judges go out of the way to clip the wings of those who are seen at the wrong side of the powers-that-be. Such dilution and stretching of law defeat the very purpose for which they are enacted.
 

Recent Posts

Dr Randall Sequeira's arrest raises questions about the criminalisation of solidarity with Adivasi communities resisting mining projects. As a doctor who chose service over comfort, his case highlight
apicture Jubel D'Cruz
16 Nov 2026
From pioneering healthcare and education to the freedom struggle, social reform and nation-building, Indian Christians have contributed immensely to the country's progress. Yet, their legacy of servic
apicture P. A. Chacko
16 Nov 2026
Sonia Gandhi's Belonging offers an intimate account of a life shaped by love, loss, duty and political upheaval. It challenges the persistent myths cooked up against her while also reflecting on India
apicture A. J. Philip
16 Nov 2026
The US midterm elections offer India an important democratic lesson: political power is never permanent, and no leader is above public scrutiny. A strong opposition, accountable government, independen
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
16 Nov 2026
Uttar Pradesh is the Congress's ultimate test of national relevance. Rebuilding its fractured coalition, addressing grievances and negotiating credible alliances are essential if it hopes to regain re
apicture John Dayal
16 Nov 2026
India's political leadership has consistently avoided unscripted public debates, hiding behind parliamentary conventions. Rahul Gandhi's challenge to Narendra Modi revives an important democratic ques
apicture Jijo Thomas Placheril
16 Nov 2026
India's fisheries boom must translate into better lives for those who sustain it. Rising production and exports mean little when traditional fishers face mounting debts, climate risks and inadequate s
apicture Jose Vattakuzhy
16 Nov 2026
Adopted from Kolkata as a toddler, Italian nurse Ramona Tratter returns to her birth country to bring healthcare and hope to marginalised communities in Bengal.
apicture CM Paul
16 Nov 2026
There's a wonderful convenience to changing a name. You can invite the press, pull a cord and have a photograph of the job being done.
apicture Robert Clements
16 Nov 2026
From Serbia to Brazil, Israel, the United States and India, people are challenging authoritarianism, corruption, communalism and war. A global awakening is gathering momentum, with youth-led movements
apicture Cedric Prakash
09 Nov 2026