Confrontational Attitudes and a Need to Focus

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
01 Jul 2024

As Prime Minister Narendra Modi embarks on his third consecutive term, there is no discernible shift in his political demeanour. His confrontational stance threatens the purpose of the Parliament. The Parliament is an institution for meaningful dialogue and problem-solving, not for political squabbles.

The 1975 Emergency is undoubtedly a dark chapter in India's democratic history. Regardless of what played behind the scenes, it warrants critical reflection and reminds us of the importance of all parties upholding democratic values and institutions. However, constantly invoking this period to provoke political opponents decades later serves no constructive purpose. Such behaviour suggests misplaced priorities.

President Murmu, PM Modi, and Speaker Dhankhar's repeated references to the Emergency seem more like a political strategy to malign the Congress Party. It is obvious that they are endeavouring to reach what they are apparently condemning. This approach is blatantly divisive. It would have put a dent in the stature of their offices, which should rise above partisan politicking, had it any left. Modi had virtually run the Parliament alone, steamrolling policies in the absence of a Leader of the Opposition. The provocation seems to be partly an expression of the displeasure felt at the loss of leeway in doing what he wanted.

The space for rational and informed discussion shrinks when the government views the Opposition as an enemy that needs to be vanquished. This confrontational stance will contribute to the already toxically charged political and communal climate and discourage consensus-building. In India, where diverse views and interests must be reconciled, the prospects for reaching agreements on important policy issues diminish when political discourse is dominated by antagonism.

What India needs at this juncture is statesmanship, not showmanship. PM Modi should have understood this after the nation agreed to disagree with him, showing its displeasure with the considerable loss of independent mandate. He should have adopted a tone of cooperation and inclusivity towards the Opposition, even if to show that he had gained some wisdom after his histrionic meditation at Vivekananda Rock Memorial.

If left unchecked, PM Modi will continue to erode the foundations of India's democratic institutions, as he has for the past decade. While the onus is on the government to create a conducive environment, the Opposition also has a crucial role. They must rise above mere obstructionism. They should stand united in holding the government accountable and participate actively in the legislative process. By doing so, they can help restore the Parliament's focus issues that threaten the nation.

Only by fostering an environment of mutual respect and cooperation can the Parliament fulfil its role as the cornerstone of Indian democracy. Or do the PM and his cronies wish to impose his "godhood" on us through another Emergency, one of their own design this time?

Recent Posts

The Supreme Court of India ruling in the Harish Rana case revives ethical questions on euthanasia—especially withdrawing nutrition and care—juxtaposing legal permissibility with Catholic teaching that
apicture Bp Gerald John Mathias
23 Mar 2026
The Supreme Court of India ruling in Harish Rana affirms the right to die with dignity, applying passive euthanasia guidelines while raising complex ethical questions on withdrawing care, patient inte
apicture Adv. Rev. Dr. George Thekkekara
23 Mar 2026
Three weeks into Operation Epic Fury, promised victories ring hollow: Iran remains resilient, oil leverage has grown, allies are uneasy, and costs mount. What was meant to project dominance instead ex
apicture A. J. Philip
23 Mar 2026
"Congress Mukt Bharat" has been a calculated strategy to weaken opposition and entrench dominance. Amid eroding institutions, constrained dissent, and majoritarian politics, India faces a pivotal mome
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
23 Mar 2026
The Viksit Bharat Shiksha Adhishthan Bill, 2025, proposes a sweeping overhaul of higher education, replacing key regulators while centralising authority and funding. The Bill undermines federalism, er
apicture Joseph Maliakan
23 Mar 2026
India's celebrated demographic dividend masks a deeper crisis: soaring graduate unemployment and a broken education-to-employment pipeline. As the 2026 report shows, degrees no longer guarantee jobs,
apicture Jaswant Kaur
23 Mar 2026
The US Commission on International Religious Freedom 2026 report sharply criticises India's religious freedom record, urging sanctions and "country of particular concern" status—charges the Government
apicture Cedric Prakash
23 Mar 2026
Amid heat, traffic and a sealed venue, slum women in Patna lit candles against a distant war that hits closest home—fuel prices, hunger, survival. Led by Sister Dorothy Fernandes, their small protest
apicture Frank Krishner
23 Mar 2026
Your eighth stage Is persecution: Forced removals, Confiscated Dalit bodies, Legal harassment.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
23 Mar 2026
The old men may continue to regulate, supervise and register the youth. But there is one small problem.
apicture Robert Clements
23 Mar 2026