Back Door Emergency

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
11 Jul 2022
Editorial - Irony of Undeclared Emergency in India

"Today, we can proudly say that India is the mother of democracy,” said Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his recent visit to Munich to attend the G 7 meeting. Addressing the Indian diaspora, he claimed: “India was a slave… now it is leading the world.” More importantly, at the summit, he, along with four other countries, signed a document on protecting the freedom of speech. But something intriguing happened back home on the same day. The Delhi police arrested Mohammed Zubair, journalist and co-founder of the reputed fact-checking website AltNews, for a tweet he did in 2018. The ‘shining’ face of India Modi portrayed in Germany was suddenly defaced by the stifling of freedom of speech and the civil society actors in India.

The hard fact is this: The government unapologetically comes up with draconian laws to put a leash on various freedoms made available by the Constitution of India. Those in the government have no qualms in trampling upon institutions to suppress the voice of the people, the soul of democracy. The rights activists are at the receiving end of the government and its agencies. Even NGOs, working in areas where the government’s development arm does not reach, are choked and made to starve for funds. The situation is akin to an undeclared emergency under the façade of democracy.  

A new trend among politicians is to unleash unbridled attack on the Constitution for the ills of their own making. The Sangh Parivar outfits and leaders were in the forefront of the boisterous demand for rewriting the Constitution. Of late, the ‘virus’ has spread from the saffron brigades to the red-flag holders. The nation got to see a glimpse of it when a CPM Minister in Kerala went hammer and tongs against the Indian Constitution terming it as a means to loot the people.

The intolerance to democratic principles and constitutional norms has seen phenomenal rise in the past few years. Protests and dissent, the corner stones of democratic form of government, have become anathema to the present regime. We have seen non-violent protesters being booked under the most pernicious UAPA and sedition laws; raising slogans against the ruling party and the government has drawn the regime’s ire; forwarding tweets critical of those in power has resulted in life behind bars for weeks and months; those speaking up and acting on behalf of tribals, Dalits and the marginalized are being branded as terrorists and thrown into jails, denying bail for years. If these are not signs of undeclared emergency, what else will we name it?

It is equally important to look at what is happening on the ruling side of the fence. Those inciting violence, as seen during the East Delhi riots last year, have gone scot-free; ruling party leaders and Sangh Parivar swamis, who have publicly screamed for taking up arms to get rid of certain sections of the society, have been treated with kid gloves. The proof of the pudding is in eating. The BJP spokesperson, whose utterance denigrating Prophet Muhammad drew worldwide condemnation and unprecedented censure from the Supreme Court, remains untouched by the long arm of the law; but innocent Stan Swamy who lived for the Tribals, was made to die in custody. This is the irony of Indian democracy. The government would do well to follow what Chief Justice of India N. V. Ramana said: ‘Recognition and protection of people's rights and dignity as well as speedy justice are imperative for functioning of a healthy democracy.’

 

Democracy in India Prime Minister Narendra Modi G7 Meeting Mohammed Zubair ALT News Delhi Police Freedom of Speech Constitution of India NGOs Undeclared Emergency Sangh Parivar UAPA Sedition Laws Tibals Dalits Delhi Riots Prophet Row CJI N.V. Ramana Fr. Stan Swamy Issue 29 2022 Indian Currents Indian Currents Magazine

Recent Posts

No fascist order is truly invincible. Its strength rests upon fear, propaganda, and institutional takeover. Once those illusions are shattered by organised resistance, authoritarian power unravels wit
apicture Adv. Jijo Thomas Placheril
03 Aug 2026
Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation may have appeased public anger, but replacing one RSS ideologue with another exposes the government's strategy: sacrifice individuals, preserve ideology. The faces may
apicture Oliver D'Souza
03 Aug 2026
History has been kinder to Manmohan Singh than contemporary politics ever was. The Supreme Court's verdict affirms that integrity may be eclipsed by accusation for a season, but truth ultimately outli
apicture A. J. Philip
03 Aug 2026
The presence of white cassocks at Jantar Mantar was a quiet revolution. In a climate where fear has silenced many institutions, the Church affirmed that protecting youth, defending constitutional free
apicture John Dayal
03 Aug 2026
No reform can make NEET equitable because its structural design favours wealth over merit. Until the examination itself is abolished, commercial coaching, educational inequality, and the exclusion of
apicture Joseph Maliakan
03 Aug 2026
India's youth have opened a chapter that extends far beyond education. Unless the deeper structures of impunity, ideological control, and erosion are confronted, every resignation will remain merely a
apicture Cedric Prakash
03 Aug 2026
Unless India's youth convert street power into sustained institutional reform, today's celebrated victory will become tomorrow's forgotten compromise, leaving the structures that produced the crisis f
apicture Joe Eruppakkatt
03 Aug 2026
At marriage time, They scan our faces For caste marks The way a scanner Searches for bombs.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
03 Aug 2026
The children have already spoken with their wounds. Now parents, grandparents, uncles and aunts, speak with your votes and your voices.
apicture Robert Clements
03 Aug 2026
There are occasions that begin as award ceremonies but end up becoming journeys through memory. The first Fr. Xavier Vadakkekara–Kerala Club Award 2026, presented to well-known journalist Unni Balakri
apicture A. J. Philip
27 Jul 2026