hidden image

Lack of Coherence in Indian Democracy

Harasankar Adhikari Harasankar Adhikari
27 Jan 2025

Just two years after India's independence, Dr Rajendra Prasad noted,

"We have prepared a democratic Constitution. But successful working of democratic institutions requires in those who have to work them willingness to respect the view points of others, capacity for compromise and accommodation. Many things which cannot be written in a Constitution are done by conventions. Let me hope that we shall show those capacities and develop those conventions. The way in which we have been able to draw this Constitution without taking recourse to voting and to divisions in Lobbies strengthens that hope ... We must admit that the defects are inherent in the situation in the country and the people at large. If the people who are elected are capable and men of character and integrity, they would be able to make the best even of a defective Constitution. If they are lacking in these, the Constitution cannot help the country. After all, a Constitution like a machine is a lifeless thing. It acquires life because of the men who control it and operate it, and India needs today nothing more than a set of honest men who will have the interest of the country before them." (Constituent Assembly Debates On 26 November, 1949)

Even after 78 years of independence, millions are hungry, have to pass the night under the open sky, suffer from ill health, are unemployed, and so on. They count their days until death. On the other hand, globalisation has yielded rampant competition between markets and consumers.

Indians, irrespective of their capacity, have entered the world of consumerism. It has facilitated opportunist groups blindly supporting a particular political party. The intellectual, social, and ecological breakdown has gradually disturbed human relations.

The world is irrational in every sense of the word - it is pitted against external and human nature. This irrationality is fundamentally anti-ecological. India is ruled by different political parties. Each party has its own strategies and methods for the "development of people." However, their prime focus is accelerating personal development by exploiting people's ignorance for their absolutist goals.

Our society is trapped within a system of growth that conflicts with nature, transforming the organic into the inorganic. Ecological movements evolve into social ecology, revealing that ecological problems stem from social hierarchies - the domination of one gender by another, of people by politics, and so on.

According to Harold H Joachim (1906), a coherent theory tries to make reality or understanding of reality rational. Coherence is a process of thinking out and giving reason to whatever our ideals may be or to whatever reality we are trying to create. It means giving a rational understanding of the reality in which we live. It does not mean that this reality is rational but that we understand how it came about and where it is going. We are now living in a period of incoherence. It denies the existence of rationality, history, and ideals and has essentially put a text under our noses and asked us to mug it.

Political violence is now significant across India, especially during elections. It becomes an event of manifest coercion, with political leaders working to establish absolute partisan control. They provoke tensions to prevent opposition, transforming elections into events of terror. There's little scope for positive political action to empower people, particularly at the grassroots level. Instead, the system nurtures a culture of political absolutism where political murders and conflicts are common.

The rejection of moral beliefs and the possibility of common people taking charge of their development leads to power consolidation among political leaders and an elite class. This closes the door to alternative development models. The rapid crisis in human relations stems from the intellectual poverty of political leaders. Abusing people's ignorance cannot sustain the building of a progressive nation.

The day will come when internal unrest helps outsiders win without a battle - a consequence of our failures.

Recent Posts

India's oldest mountain range is facing its most modern threat. As mining expands and legal definitions narrow, the Aravallis' role as a climate shield, water source, and wildlife corridor is being qu
apicture Joseph Jerald SJ
05 Jan 2026
India was built by defying religious orthodoxy, not sanctifying it. Science, education and equality advanced when prejudice was challenged—and regressed whenever cultural nationalism revives the fears
apicture A. J. Philip
05 Jan 2026
The end of a year offers individuals, institutions, nations, and the global community an opportunity for introspection and learning from the experiences of the past twelve months. Life is a blend of s
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 Jan 2026
The 2025 Zilla Panchayat elections exposed how local self-governance in Goa has been overtaken by high-stakes party politics. BJP's all-out mobilisation contrasted sharply with the fragmented Oppositi
apicture Pachu Menon
05 Jan 2026
In recent years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has repeatedly reached out to India's Christian community. On several occasions, especially around Christmas, he has visited churches, hosted gatherings w
apicture Bishop Savio Fernandes
05 Jan 2026
Christmas violence against Christians is diagnostic. It is a stress test of India's constitutional guarantees. Vigilantes policing public celebration with impunity is an attack on civic space.
apicture Oliver D'Souza
05 Jan 2026
Give work to all the hands Give wages to all the families
apicture Prakash Louis
05 Jan 2026
I was born like anyone else. Yet I was never treated like anyone else. The name Pariah was given to me. And its meaning was carved into my skin.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
05 Jan 2026
While Xi Jinping was at Mahabalipuram admiring Indian art and listening to Modi's 'political wisdom,' the People's Liberation Army was pushing the Chinese frontier in the Galwan Valley. The Chinese sp
apicture Archbp Thomas Menamparampil
05 Jan 2026
The oath is complete. Applause follows. And as the fake fog of falsehood settles over the nation once again, truth is the victim, as it has been the last ten years...
apicture Robert Clements
05 Jan 2026