hidden image

Relationship of Israel and the Church: Jesus of Nazareth or Barabbas?

Dr Shailendra Awale Dr Shailendra Awale
17 Jun 2024

Israel as a chosen people of God and as a nation-state is always discussed passionately, often compromising its objectivity. The ongoing military conflict (since October 2023) between Hamas, the elected government of Gaza, and Israel under Netanyahu's rule has posed serious ethical and theological problems. The Church and its members worldwide are divided on the issues, lacking comprehensive and objective analysis of its implications. In his book, "Should Christians Support the Present State of Israel?", renowned medical practitioner Prof Dr Mohan Z Mani (retired Dermatology professor) gives theological, historical, and political perspectives on the critical issue. His objective analysis makes the categorical assertion that we, the Church and believers, are given the same choice that Pontius Pilate gave the Jews, whether to prefer Jesus of Nazareth or Barabbas (militant murderer).

Dr Mani graduated from Christian Medical College, Ludhiana, and is known for his evangelical teachings. He has been active in biblical studies since his student days through his work in reputed Christian mission institutes. When there are clear divisions between ecumenical and evangelical churches, families often get diverse opinions, so there is a need for such a comprehensive analysis, an easy-to-read and brief booklet of merely 64 pages.

The book results from his deep concern and passion for the prevalent discussions to support the Israel State under Netanyahu. His concern and his training in the medical sciences led to a systematic study of biblical teaching, research in historical developments, and its socio-political implications. In his extended book-length essay titled "Should Christians support the present state of Israel?", he explores the relationship between the state of Israel and the Church. As of May 21, 2024, over 37000 people (35562 Palestinian and 1478 Israeli) were killed, including 105 journalists (100 Palestinian, 2 Israeli, 3 Lebanese) and 224 aid workers. Such atrocities are condemnable even with the Old Testament standards of "an eye for an eye".

Hamas is considered a militant revolutionary fighting for self-rule, much like other historical figures, while Israel continues her conquest and establishing settlements as a fulfilment of the divine promise. However, in the present political and social understanding, such military adventures are not advisable, but they are deplorable, too. The Zionist theology has controlled the narrative, forcing the Church to support present Zionist, unbelieving, and atheist Israel.

Dr Mani has presented historical information (geopolitical decisions as a part of the colonial agenda of Great Britain and France then) and biblical references (Zionism) that have led to the present situation as a problem profile. The actions of Netanyahu and his team are against all international laws: Israelis are the interlopers and usurpers of Palestine. He gives the history of occupation, regimes, and control of Judah, Galilee, and Samaria. The conflict between the Replacement Theology held by the Church for 2000 years and the Restoration Theology propagated for the last 200 years is presented well, bringing theological clarity.

The author has presented more than 20 quotations from the New Testament suggesting the Church has replaced Israel as God's people. There is no need to revert to the old covenant nor try to mix the new covenant with the old covenant as desired by Christian Zionism. After that, the author addresses the myths about Israel and specific arguments propagated by Christian Zionists and misguided bible teachers. These myths are readings from the Old Testament presented as arguments for restoration theology.

There is a separate section describing various strategic and geopolitical events aimed at imperial and colonial expansion and further leading to the Israel conflict; it covers British hegemony after a successful campaign in Waterloo in 1815, the advent of the Christian Zionist movement led by John Darby, Anglican Priest turned Plymouth Brethren and Cyrus Scofield, American Dispensationalist, Palestinian Arab support to British forces to evict Ottoman Turks, but the British failed to fulfil the treaty. It came up with the Balfour Declaration, a promise to Rothschild, a Jewish financier and interlocutor, which finally led to Two Nation Solutions, Nakba of 1948, to the present events; all these forces contributed to the Zionist agenda and annihilation of Palestinians from their homeland. This section is a testimony of the author's scholarship in geopolitical and strategic disciplines.

In the preface, the author has dedicated the booklet to the 32,000 innocent Palestinian civilians of Gaza and journalists and aid workers who met an early and unexpected death at the hands of the state of Israel under Netanyahu. In the closing chapter, the author has underlined peaceful coexistence by accepting two-nation solutions as a way forward. Yet the observations, analysis, and remarks are very comprehensive and objective.

Since his student days, Dr Mani has been involved in a Christian evangelical environment. Further, he admits that when Israel took over Jerusalem in June 1967, he considered it a fulfilment of prophecy. He adds that, at that time, he did not know any alternative explanations and felt that Israel was the key to prophecy, a softer Christian Zionism. So, his journey is remarkable and convincing. Learning the milestones or motives for that journey and the changes in perspectives would have been worthwhile.

This booklet is not against the majority of peaceful and tolerant world Jewry who practice Judaism. Still, it holds the atheistic and regenerative State of Israel under the present dispensation to account for its aggressive actions. The proper and final Restoration of the believing Jewish remnant could be fulfilled just before or during the Millennium. I strongly recommend the book for every church member and obedient follower of Christ as they have to choose between Jesus of Nazareth and Criminal Barabbas.

Recent Posts

On October 28, the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts undergoing life imprisonment for the gangrape of Bilkis Bano and the murder of her family, including a two-month-old infant, during the 20
apicture Cedric Prakash
23 Nov 2026
Every day, thousands of cases are disposed of by courts in Delhi. It is humanly impossible for a handful of legal correspondents to report every case, let alone understand its wider implications. Some
apicture A. J. Philip
23 Nov 2026
I was motivated to write this article by reading Sonia Gandhi's memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love. As Sonia Gandhi recounts, she came to India because she loved a man, Rajiv Gandhi.
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
23 Nov 2026
The growing number of attacks on churches, prayer gatherings and Christian institutions in West Bengal demands more than routine assurances from the BJP government. It demands accountability, impartia
apicture Dr Suresh Mathew
23 Nov 2026
In a Republic whose Constitution guarantees equal citizenship and freedom of conscience, parties organised around religious identity continue to shape electoral competition but have little future of t
apicture John Dayal
23 Nov 2026
Yahweh's mission of liberation, justice and empowerment is inherently political. Inspired by the prophets and Jesus, Christians are called to move beyond passive faith and engage actively in public li
apicture Prof. Raj Irudaya, SJ
23 Nov 2026
Following the release of Sonia Gandhi's autobiography, "Belonging: A Journey of Love," on November 10, 2026, it became an instant bestseller. At the official launch on November 16, Anant Padmanabhan,
apicture G Ramachandram
23 Nov 2026
And who knows? At the next summit, when the photograph is done, and somebody says, "Shall we move?" you might be the one to say, "In a minute. I think that lady at the back had a question!"
apicture Robert Clements
23 Nov 2026
Dr Randall Sequeira's arrest raises questions about the criminalisation of solidarity with Adivasi communities resisting mining projects. As a doctor who chose service over comfort, his case highlight
apicture Jubel D'Cruz
16 Nov 2026
From pioneering healthcare and education to the freedom struggle, social reform and nation-building, Indian Christians have contributed immensely to the country's progress. Yet, their legacy of servic
apicture P. A. Chacko
16 Nov 2026