hidden image

Indian Democracy's Moment Of Reckoning

Mathew John Mathew John
16 Sep 2024

Here are some snippets that I gleaned from the Godi news media on September 4: a) 500 SEBI employees write to Finance Ministry on toxic work culture under Madhabi Buch; b) Thane magistrate's court cancels bail to cow vigilantes who brutalised a 72-year old Muslim; c) Subhash Chandra of Zee Entertainment, issues a press release alleging corruption against the chairperson of SEBI.

For a long ten years, when our democracy was under assault, happenings like the kind mentioned above that could cause embarrassment to the regime were either nipped in the bud or news about them squelched before they hit the newsstands. Everything changed on June 4 - that red-letter day when emperor Humpty-Dumpty had a great fall, and we recovered our freedom. Today, the power dynamics have shifted decisively in favour of transparency, perhaps a fitting time to play back to Modi the borrowed Bob Dylan quote that he tauntingly spouted at the Global Citizens festival in 2016 soon after the demonetisation debacle: "don't try to criticise what you can't understand… the times, they are a changing!" Life has come full circle!

Khalil Gibran was spot on about the indispensability of human freedom: "Life without liberty is like a body without spirit." The Lok Sabha election and the fractured mandate of June 4 marked the day of deliverance for all Indians who believe in the idea of India that our founding fathers envisaged. I also realised that freedom is not just good for the soul but for one's physical well-being. Of a sudden, the heebie-jeebies in the pit of the stomach have gone, and so have the acid reflux, the sleeplessness and other psychogenic problems, and there's almost a spring in the step of the old dog. Let me tell you – freedom is an unmitigated good!

For ten interminable years, India's story was about inhumanity, bigotry and unspeakable cruelty; it was about the deliberate, organised and hate-filled othering of the Muslim; it was about complicit institutions, a partisan judiciary and law enforcement machinery. Undergirding such overt forms of oppression was what that most remarkable playwright-philosopher-politician of the twentieth century, Václav Havel, called the "technique of existential pressure" that embraced the whole of society and every individual. It was a nameless terror – "a hideous spider whose invisible web runs right through the whole of society"- that demanded unquestioning obedience and went to the absurd extent of citizens banging thalis and lighting diyas on command from on high. Everyone was positioned as either a victim or a supporter of the regime.

This grim period showed people for what they were – ugly, bad or good. Top of the list of despicable collaborators was the potentially most powerful segment of what constitutes civil society – the self-serving, cowardly middle class, ever ready to kowtow to the regime for personal gain, informing on their fellow citizens, revelling in the hedonistic consumer culture and heedless of the injustice and misery all around. Equally, if not more, reprehensible was the conduct of the corporate honchos and the business community in general, who sold their souls to the regime and, in tandem with their political benefactors, fattened off the land.

It was left to the powerless, i.e. the poor and the dispossessed, to rescue our democracy. And they did! Like in 1977, when they booted out the despotic Indira Gandhi, once again, against all odds, the poor of this country delivered a verdict against 'tanashahi,' denying the BJP a majority on its own in the Lok Sabha election. Of a sudden, the blinding light of freedom has dispelled the darkness that had enveloped us for ten years. Our chaotic, vibrant democracy has come roaring back! After being on the ropes for years on end, a rejuvenated Opposition, fortified by their impressive numbers, took Parliament by storm in the recent Monsoon session and, to extend the boxing analogy, pummelled the ruling party with a barrage of thunderous jabs. The look of hangdog sheepishness punctuated by impotent outrage on the faces of the two bullies was a sight to behold. On all counts, it was a technical knockout!

It's no longer a one-way street. Shackled by the constraints of a coalition, the compulsive authoritarian has been forced to submit to the bumpy dynamics of democratic functioning with its checks and balances. Legislation that hitherto was cleared by an imperious Parliament without discussion has now hit hard rock. The Broadcast Bill and the Waqf (Amendment) Bill, which are unmistakable confirmations that Modi's mentality has not changed, have been withdrawn. And so has the notification regarding lateral entry into the intermediate rungs of government.

The judiciary, which was, for the most part, a covert accomplice of the authoritarian regime, seems to have responded haltingly to the gust of freedom that has blown our way. Its recent cheering judgements that 'bail is the rule and jail the exception' even in UAPA and PMLA cases were begging to be made for years. As pointed out by Ravish Kumar in his recent forensic analysis of the subject, the half-hearted, ambivalent and even contrary judgements by the Supreme Court have not adequately served the cause of justice. While Manish Sisodia, K Kavitha, and some others arrested in connection with the Delhi Liquor Policy case have finally been granted bail, Umar Khalid, the heroic student activist, remains in jail even after four years on the manifestly trumped-up charges of inciting the 2020 Delhi riots. In contrast, Kapil Mishra, whose hate-filled, incendiary speech triggered the riots according to most sources, has been untouched, which speaks volumes about our cock-eyed justice system.

It is curious that whereas the Supreme Court jumped into the fray in the RG Kar case by taking suo motu cognisance, it has maintained an apathetic silence in the face of the SEBI-Adani scandal revelations, which is worrying. Despite irrefutable evidence that both the Expert committee (was MV Kamath the former ICICI honcho an innocent inclusion?) that it had appointed to examine the Hindenburg allegations and SEBI were guilty of dereliction in the remit entrusted to them, the Supreme Court has so far maintained a puzzling aloofness. Hopefully, with democracy back on track, the Supreme Court will be under increasing public pressure to do the right thing by the law.

The tepid electoral outcome for the BJP has restored some sanity in India's External Affairs ministry, which functioned as the PM's publicity bureau for ten years, single-mindedly focussed on promoting the 'Vishwaguru' and his business cronies. Despite the electoral setback, initially, Modi acted like it was business and junket time as usual. But the lukewarm reception at the G7 summit in Italy, and then the universal criticism of his defiant supportive bear-hug of Putin in Moscow hours after a Russian strike on a Kyiv children's hospital, made him change tactics.

There followed what should be called a balancing penitential visit to Ukraine. Still, his melodramatic expression of solicitude for the deaths and suffering caused by the war cut no ice with President Zelensky, who was not fooled and rebuffed the PM in no uncertain terms. The image of the self-proclaimed peace-mediator lies in tatters! Who said that democracy is an unending exercise in humbling the arrogant?

The positive signs are India's new, much-needed efforts to enhance cooperation and understanding with our neighbours, including Pakistan. There is now open acknowledgement that the border "dispute" and uneasy relations with China are indicative that we have a "special China problem" over and above the world's "general China problem." Will the government finally admit Chinese incursions into our territory? It was supremely ironic but most heartening to hear Modi's appeal to Bangladesh to protect and look after the interests of its minorities, including Hindus. He should heed Muhammad Yunus's cautionary advice and make sure that his buddy - the smiling terminator - keeps her own counsel while under protective cover in India.

There is no doubt that the trappings of democracy are back, but it would be a mistake to conclude that these basic practices engendered by our new-found freedom are what democracy is all about. In truth, they only provide the preliminary groundwork for the more difficult tasks ahead. To quote Babasaheb Ambedkar: "Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the base of it social democracy. What does social democracy mean? It means a way of life which recognises liberty, equality and fraternity as the principles of life."

We are nowhere near the kind of democracy we want to be! Only a society that has overcome prejudice and hatred and ensures equal treatment to all its citizens can claim to be a truly just society. Regrettably, the noble ideals set forth in the Preamble, which spells out the resolve "to secure justice, liberty and equality for all its citizens and promote fraternity among all", remain more elusive than ever.

Of the cherished values that attest to our commitment to secular humanism, the greatest and most neglected is fraternity, perhaps because it is least amenable to political action. As a wise woman once observed, the State can prevent me from coveting my neighbour's property, but it cannot oblige me, by law, to love my neighbour. Yet, the success of our pursuit to be a strong, united and happy country ultimately depends on whether we love one another – regardless of how we look, worship, eat, or love.

Sadly, in the last ten years under Modi, our worst impulses have been unleashed. Fear and hate have consumed us, and we are more divided than ever. There is little empathy and decency in our public discourse. The persecution and lynching of Muslims is a daily occurrence even today, and it no longer excites interest, let alone outrage. The cruellest irony is that the man who has spearheaded the oppression and 'othering' of an entire community recently expressed concern in Brunei that whereas the world has moved on, in India, we are still fixated on Hindu-Muslim polarity. Our PM has clearly 'lost it'!

What's at stake is not just our democracy but our survival as a united Republic. At this dangerous time, we need a leader who can think beyond himself and bring people together instead of dividing them to retain power. This country certainly does not need any more of the Modi leadership style.

For the good of this country, the Shahenshah and the Shah must demit office without further ado. Given the grim state of affairs, the best quick-fix solution is for the BJP (in truth, the RSS) to nominate Nitin Gadkari as PM. Although ideologically pledged to the Nagpur doctrine, he is most like Atal Bihari Vajpayee among the present leaders and commands respect for his liberal worldview, administrative acumen and commitment to democratic ideals. Significantly, his constituents - Hindu and Muslim - know him to be even-handed and just in his dealings. He could bring the much-needed healing touch that our polity so desperately needs.

Recent Posts

"Traditional" Christmas celebrations fail to highlight the pain, rejection, and humility surrounding Jesus' birth. We must question our focus on festive traditions. Let us recognise modern-day margina
apicture M L Satyan
23 Dec 2024
The Church, by any measure, cannot fully provide compensatory justice to Dalit Christians, who have been forced to live as outcastes for thousands of years, but it has the capacity to negotiate and pr
apicture Dr Anthoniraj Thumma
23 Dec 2024
The Artha??stra, which he is supposed to have written, was actually composed by many persons over many decades. In any case, Chanakya's doctrines did not help India. Every foreigner could easily captu
apicture A. J. Philip
23 Dec 2024
Christmas now revolves around Santa, commerce, and grand celebrations, sidelining its core message of love, forgiveness, and compassion. Christmas urges generosity, transcending divisions, and fosteri
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
23 Dec 2024
Seventy-five years after adopting the Constitution, India faces a stark disconnect between its ideals and practices. Ambedkar's vision of justice and equality is overshadowed by systemic failures, cas
apicture Jaswant Kaur
23 Dec 2024
, we need to understand that the Constitution-making process was the biggest effort of reconciliation in Indian society. Baba Saheb Ambedkar understood this very well, as did the Congress leadership a
apicture Vidya Bhushan Rawat
23 Dec 2024
Christmas symbolises humanity's relentless search for truth. It prompts and unites human desires for metaphysical understanding, transcending materialism and relativism. Embracing truth offers purpose
apicture Peter Fernandes
23 Dec 2024
Tavleen Singh critiques the Taliban's misogyny but overlooks parallels between religious fundamentalism and Hindu nationalism. Both enforce oppressive norms, targeting women and minorities, cloaked as
apicture Ram Puniyani
23 Dec 2024
Donald Trump and Narendra Modi are adept at divisive rhetoric, authoritarianism, rewriting history and exploiting their nations' fault lines. Both have been fuelling communal and cultural divides whil
apicture Mathew John
23 Dec 2024
Listen to choirs this Christmas season, but even as you do, take back with you a deeper lesson than the words the songwriters wrote, realising that choral harmony could be a wonderful way to live as a
apicture Robert Clements
23 Dec 2024