hidden image

Dialoguing with Dissent..!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
11 Mar 2024

The present government seems to be pressing all the right buttons to return for a third term. They are projecting the prime minister as a powerful figure in the international arena while also showing that all welfare schemes at home stem from his office. They have used the' religion card' extremely well and have shown themselves, whether truthfully or falsely, as a party above corruption.

All's fair in love or war, and I guess the same applies to politics, but an angle where they are seen wanting is their dialogue with dissent.

Here, they have no dialogue whatsoever, and this could be their Achilles heel.

In a democracy, your strength is recognised by how you handle dissent. Unfortunately, most powerful leaders ultimately fall because of a growing chorus of people saying their questions are not being heard, answered, or met with thundering silence.

Parliament was built for dialogue; if not, the old building, once decommissioned, should not have been replaced by a newer, bigger one. "We don't need a Parliament building, because once we have the mandate, we can do what we want," should have been the cry of any victorious party after the elections, as those whose political parties had lost took the next train home.

No, the losers stay on in Parliament, their purpose now being to scrutinise and challenge continuously. That is their job. But to the present ruling party, this is anti-national and seditious, though truth be told, dissent is what they are being paid to do.

Dissent, as a Supreme Court ruling has just said, is the right of every individual in our country. 'Right to dissent, lawful,' ruled the honourable judges sternly.

Which makes dialoguing with dissent essential.

Nobody in power likes dissent. As parents, we cringe when our children stand up and tell us they do not agree with us. However, how that disagreement is handled makes the same child either strong or resentful. When we are unable to have patience and understanding in explaining our actions to our children, we finally produce angry, resentful and unhealthy adults.

Today, there is resentment in the country about how dissent is handled. Disagreement with government policies either lands citizens in jail, has the ED knocking at their doors or has the mob's fury unleashed.

Many years ago, a person from Coimbatore who was President of an international organisation called the Round Table told me, "When an ordinary member during an AGM asks me a question, even if it is a stupid question, how I answer him, the respect I treat him or her with, is what the others in the room will observe and laud or nail me for!"

Wise words!

Though the present ruling party is pressing all the right buttons, they need to learn how to dialogue with dissent...!

bobsbanter@gmail.com

Recent Posts

Does religion today indeed lead to God? Why is there growing religious intolerance, violence, and manipulation? True religion advocates understanding the core values of faith, promoting unity, and emb
apicture Dr Martin Valiyaparambil VC
14 Oct 2024
Even as India bade a tearful farewell to a giant of a man, let us not bid adieu to the values the Tata name so firmly established in the country. For many decades, people swore by the brand name Tata.
apicture Robert Clements
14 Oct 2024
Sonam Wangchuk's detainment at the Delhi border reflects the government's growing fear of public support for peaceful movements, challenging the state's neglect. Sonam's ability to mobilise people and
apicture A. J. Philip
07 Oct 2024
The concept of political spirituality emphasises empathy, humility, and connection with the masses. It advocates for governance rooted in ethical responsibility. Inspired by Gandhi's approach, leaders
apicture Roy Alex SJ
07 Oct 2024
Despite the Supreme Court declaring electoral bonds unconstitutional, no action was taken against those involved. A Bengaluru Special Court allowed an FIR against Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman a
apicture Michael G.
07 Oct 2024
The judiciary's intervention in Atul Kumar's case highlights the critical role of a fair legal system. The court ensured educational equity by considering socio-economic circumstances, emphasising tha
apicture Dr John Singarayar
07 Oct 2024
The Supreme Court's reminder to Andhra Pradesh's Chandrababu Naidu to keep religion out of politics is overdue, given the BJP's longstanding use of Hindutva for political gain. This message is crucial
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
07 Oct 2024
In the early twentieth century, as militant nationalism swept across India, Rabindranath Tagore emerged as a radical departure from the dominant nationalist ideologies. His approach, grounded in human
apicture Sacaria Joseph
07 Oct 2024
Under Modi's reign, Indian Railways (IR) abandoned its social responsibility, prioritising vanity projects like Vande Bharat trains for elites over ordinary passengers. Cultism, hero worship, and imag
apicture Mathew John
07 Oct 2024
The BJP-RSS's inconsistency in addressing domestic crises contradicts their global assertions of democracy and fairness. While preaching unity and collective strength on the world stage, their actions
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
07 Oct 2024