hidden image

2019 Jamia Case: Dissent, Free Speech & Protests

Joseph Maliakan Joseph Maliakan
27 Feb 2023
The court is duty bound to lean towards an interpretation which protects the rights of the accused, given the power disparity between them and the state machinery.

The February 4 order of Additional Sessions Judge Arul Verma of the Saket Court discharging JNU student Sharjeel Imam and student activists Safoora Zagar, Asif Iqbal Tanha and eight others in the December 2019 Jamia violence case should be etched in golden letters in the hearts of all freedom-loving people everywhere.

Verma’s discharge order is very significant because it will have a major salutary effect on how the innumerable cases filed under the draconian Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA) and various sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) without proper evidence or investigation are dealt.

The case pertains to the incidence of violence that erupted at Jamia Millia Islamia University in December 2019 after a clash between police and the people protesting against the Citizens Amendment Act (CAA).

The FIR alleged offences of rioting and unlawful assembly under several sections of the IPC. Ironically, cases were registered only against the protesting students and no effort was made to book policemen who entered the Jamia campus and brutally beat up even those in the university library.

Discharging the accused, Verma said “dissent is nothing but an extension of the invaluable fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression contained in Article 19 of the Constitution of India, subject to the restrictions contained. It is therefore a right which we are sworn to uphold.”

ASJ Verma further said that, as laid down by the Supreme Court in P. Vijayan vs the State of Kerala, the court is duty bound to lean towards an interpretation which protects the rights of the accused, given the power disparity between them and the state machinery.

In fact in his concluding remarks, which are most significant, Verma said to safeguard the citizens’ fundamental right to freedom of speech and assembly, in all its actions the State was obliged to draw a clear line between dissent and insurrection, especially in the context of protests like the present one where the prosecution sought to blur them.

“Furthermore, such a police action is detrimental to the liberty of citizens who choose to exercise their fundamental right to peacefully assemble and protest. Liberty of protesting citizens should not have been lightly interfered with,” ASJ Verma pointed out.

In its detailed order the court observed that the police was unable to apprehend the “actual perpetrators” and “surely managed to rope them (accused) as scapegoats in the matter.” The prosecution was also severely indicted for filing “ill-conceived chargesheets.”

Additional Sessions Judge Arul Verma said that the police have “arbitrarily chosen” to array some people from the protesting crowd as accused and others as police witnesses. This “cherry picking” is absolutely detrimental to the precept of fairness, the court said.

The court further observed that mere presence at the protest site without overt acts cannot lead to implication as accused, and said that the prosecution has ex facie been launched in a “perfunctory and cavalier fashion” against them. To allow such persons undergo rigmarole of long drawn trial does not augur well for the criminal justice system of our country, Judge Verma added.

“The desideratum is for the investigative agencies to discern the difference between dissent and insurrection. The latter has to be quelled indisputably. However, the former has to be given space, a forum, for dissent is perhaps reflective of something which pricks the citizen’s conscience,” the order said.

In the Jamia violence case, the police had originally filed a chargesheet only against Mohammad llyas on April 21, 2020. This was then followed by a supplementary chargesheet against 11 other accused persons. A third supplementary chargesheet was filed as recently as February 1, 2023. The prosecution tried to establish that the witnesses had identified the accused persons on the basis of some photographs.

In this context the court observed that the Delhi Police failed to adduce fresh evidence and rather sought to present old facts in the garb of “further investigation” by filing supplementary chargesheets.

“In the present case, it has been most unusual of the police to file not one chargesheet but three supplementary chargesheets, with really nothing new to offer. This filing of a slew of chargesheets must cease, else this juggernaut reflects something beyond mere prosecution, and would have the effect of trampling the rights of the accused persons,” the order said.

It further said that there were no eyewitnesses who could substantiate the version of the police that the accused were in any way involved in the commission of the offences. It said that no test identification parade was held until filing of the third supplementary chargesheet and that the photographs and videos only demonstrate that the accused were standing behind barricades.

"There is nothing on record to even prima facie suggest that the accused herein were part of some riotous mob… Surely prosecution cannot be launched on the basis of conjectures and surmises and chargesheets definitely cannot be filed on the basis of probabilities,” the order said.

The court also pointed out in the present case the investigative agencies should have incorporated the use of technology, or have gathered credible intelligence, and then only it should have embarked on “galvanizing the judicial system” against the accused. Else it should have abstained from filing such ill-conceived chargesheets against persons whose role was confined only to being part of a protest.

Recent Posts

On October 28, the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts undergoing life imprisonment for the gangrape of Bilkis Bano and the murder of her family, including a two-month-old infant, during the 20
apicture Cedric Prakash
23 Nov 2026
Every day, thousands of cases are disposed of by courts in Delhi. It is humanly impossible for a handful of legal correspondents to report every case, let alone understand its wider implications. Some
apicture A. J. Philip
23 Nov 2026
I was motivated to write this article by reading Sonia Gandhi's memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love. As Sonia Gandhi recounts, she came to India because she loved a man, Rajiv Gandhi.
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
23 Nov 2026
The growing number of attacks on churches, prayer gatherings and Christian institutions in West Bengal demands more than routine assurances from the BJP government. It demands accountability, impartia
apicture Dr Suresh Mathew
23 Nov 2026
In a Republic whose Constitution guarantees equal citizenship and freedom of conscience, parties organised around religious identity continue to shape electoral competition but have little future of t
apicture John Dayal
23 Nov 2026
Yahweh's mission of liberation, justice and empowerment is inherently political. Inspired by the prophets and Jesus, Christians are called to move beyond passive faith and engage actively in public li
apicture Prof. Raj Irudaya, SJ
23 Nov 2026
Following the release of Sonia Gandhi's autobiography, "Belonging: A Journey of Love," on November 10, 2026, it became an instant bestseller. At the official launch on November 16, Anant Padmanabhan,
apicture G Ramachandram
23 Nov 2026
And who knows? At the next summit, when the photograph is done, and somebody says, "Shall we move?" you might be the one to say, "In a minute. I think that lady at the back had a question!"
apicture Robert Clements
23 Nov 2026
Dr Randall Sequeira's arrest raises questions about the criminalisation of solidarity with Adivasi communities resisting mining projects. As a doctor who chose service over comfort, his case highlight
apicture Jubel D'Cruz
16 Nov 2026
From pioneering healthcare and education to the freedom struggle, social reform and nation-building, Indian Christians have contributed immensely to the country's progress. Yet, their legacy of servic
apicture P. A. Chacko
16 Nov 2026